Book review: “Unconditional Parenting” by Alfie Kohn
Book Review: “Unconditional Parenting” by Alfie Kohn
I often recommended to parents an article by Alfie Kohn called “5 Reasons to Stop Saying Good Boy/Good Girl”. And I’ve been told many times that parents have found his book “Unconditional Parenting” the most useful parenting book they had read. (…)
1. Working with (instead of doing to)
The biggest message I have taken away from Alfie Kohn’s book is his emphasis to shift towards “working with” our kids as opposed to “doing to”.
“Doing to” strategies are things like threatening, bribing and rewarding our kids as ways to control our children. Instead some “working with” strategies he suggests are:
- Reconsider your requests – for example, instead of asking “how do I get my child to eat?” instead look at your assumptions, look at what your child needs, and place your focus on offering nutritious food instead.
- Move to unconditionality – I think we all love our children no matter what they have done; however, we don’t always act this way. Moving toward unconditionality means acting in a way where your child knows you love them for WHO they are, no matter WHAT they do.
- Talk less, ask more
- Assume the best from your child – we don’t always see what has happened and know what has gone on. Instead of assuming the worst, you can also assume the best!
- Give age-appropriate choices
2. Use of praise, rewards and punishment
Alfie Kohn believes that praise, rewards and punishments are all ways of controlling our children. These provide extrinsic motivation to behave in the way we want. But he says this is the wrong type of motivation – better for it to come from the child themselves.
For example, instead of putting a child into time out if he has hit another child, you can get the child to work out what to do to make amends. “I think she feels so bad she is crying. What can you do to make her feel better?” By ending with a question, you give your child a chance to come up with something (even a pre-verbal child!).
3. Use of testing in schools
Alfie Kohn is also very critical of the schools in the US (and many other countries) where there is a lot of focus on test scores. He would like to see school implement interactive, interdisciplinary, and question-based learning to get a deep understanding as opposed to just learning facts. Sounds like a Montessori education would meet many of these requirements.
Hopefully I’ve inspired you to hear more from Alfie Kohn. You can find some of his talks on Youtube. Or you can read his book “Unconditional Parenting” (…)
Référence: http://www.themontessorinotebook.com/unconditional-parenting/
Beaucoup de guides pratiques à l’usage des parents posent comme objectif implicite : « Comment obtenir l’obéissance des enfants ? » Et proposent différentes techniques pour contrôler les enfants.
Ce livre n’est pas une énième méthode ! Alfie Kohn préfère poser la question suivante : « Quels sont les besoins des enfants et comment résoudre les conflits ? »
Il s’agit de faire avec les enfants plutôt que de faire faire aux enfants.
Un besoin fondamental des enfants est l’amour inconditionnel. C’est ainsi qu’ils sont assurés d’être aimés et acceptés quoi qu’ils fassent. Hélas, les approches conventionnelles des punitions, récompenses et toute forme de contrôle, transmettent aux enfants qu’ils sont aimés uniquement lorsqu’ils nous obéissent ou lorsqu’ils nous impressionnent. Sois aimable ! Autrement dit, fais en sorte de mériter notre amour !
L’auteur cite de nombreuses recherches qui montrent la nocivité de toutes ces méthodes. Ce livre nous emmène dans une profonde réflexion sur nos pensées, nos sentiments et nos actes envers nos enfants. Enfin, il invite tous les parents à réfléchir, à se reconnecter avec leur instinct premier, naturellement bon, pour devenir de meilleurs parents.Référence: https://www.amazon.fr/Aimer-Enfants-Inconditionnellement-Alfie-Kohn/dp/2916032487